NJSIAA Ice Hockey Tournament: Seton Hall Prep loses to Pingry in overtime, season ends

WEST ORANGE, N.J. — In a heartbreaking end to the 2023-24 season, the Seton Hall Prep ice hockey team lost 4-3 in overtime to Pingry in the first round of the New Jersey Interscholastic Athletic Association Ice Hockey Tournament. It was a narrow loss. . The Pirates' hopes for tournament glory were quickly dashed in this exciting game at Richard J. Cody Arena on Tuesday, February 20th.

Early game advantage

The game started with Seton Hall Prep showing skill and teamwork early. Sophomore Zachary Cumming led the Pirates in scoring, scoring just 1:39 into the game after a scramble in front of the net, with an assist from junior Aidan Kelleher. The Pirates' momentum continued, with sophomore John Renthro hitting a slap shot from the left circle and just 1:10 later doubling their lead to 2-0 thanks to an assist from senior Hudson Rocheville. This early advantage set the tone for what is expected to be a successful outing for Seton Hall Prep.

The turning of the tide and the despair of overtime

As the match progressed, the tide began to turn. Pingree found a rhythm and managed to claw his way back, eventually tying the game and sending the game into overtime. The all-or-nothing overtime game was filled with tension on both sides. Despite an early advantage and fighting spirit, Seton Hall Prep ultimately lost 4-3 on Pingry's winning goal, dashing the Pirates' hopes of making it to the tournament.

Reflection and future outlook

Although the loss was bitter, it was a learning opportunity for a young Seton Hall Prep team. Key players like Zachary Cumming and John Renthro are only sophomores, so this team has a bright future. There is no doubt that the experience gained from close games under pressure will help the team grow. Looking ahead, Pirates are ready to come back even stronger and have their sights set on not only making it to the top of next season's tournaments, but also picking up wins.